So now I live off of this stuff. It's not the same but its still pretty good.
I found these today on cookiemadness.net and am going to play around with them a little more. I present to you
No-Bake Grape Nut Peanut Butter Squares. These make very good snacks, and because of the fibre from the Grape Nuts and protein from the PB they're very guilt free!
You'll find the original recipe here at www.cookiemadness.net/2011/06/no-bake-grape-nuts-peanut-butter-bars/ My changes are changing up the sugar types and quantities and adding in cinnamon.
This is my version so far:
1/3 cup golden syrup (white corn syrup in the States)
1/4 cup brown sugar (I mixed light and dark)
1 1/3 overflowing cups of Grape Nuts
And after being left over night in the fridge, the sickly sweetness from the syrup had almost entirely been replaced by a lovely peanuty crunch. Yum.